Practical Skills I: Planning
Revise Practical Skills I: Planning for Physics (IAL) — revision notes and instant AI marking. Free to start.
Planning an Experiment
Big idea: Good experimental planning is just answering four questions properly before you ever touch the apparatus — Every mark in this topic comes from justifying why you chose an instrument or method, not just naming it.
📋 Chapter Summary
- Identifying apparatus: every experiment needs the right tool for the quantity you're measuring — rulers, balances, meters, and more precise tools like the micrometer and vernier calipers.
- Range & resolution: range = min/max an instrument can read; resolution = smallest increment it can detect. Resolution sets the uncertainty.
- Calibration: checking an instrument against a known value (e.g. zero error, ice/steam points) so its readings can be trusted.
- Measuring variables: match the instrument's resolution to the size of the quantity — a ruler for cm, calipers for mm, a micrometer for tiny lengths.
- Control variables & fair tests: independent variable is deliberately changed, dependent variable is measured, everything else must be held constant.
- Repeat readings: improve accuracy/reliability and let you spot anomalies — but aren't always practical (time-dependent or heat-affected experiments).
- Health & safety: always name the hazard the specific fix — a bare hazard statement rarely earns the mark.
- Data collection: standard form, consistent significant figures, and calculating means (allowed one extra s.f.) turn raw numbers into usable data.
- Uncertainty vs. systematic error: uncertainty is the "wobble range" around a reading; a systematic error is a consistent offset from the true value, visible as a graph not passing through the origin.
- Wider implications: commercial, legal, ethical, social, economic and environmental factors all shape how science is used and funded.
🔧 1. Identifying Apparatus
Think of apparatus selection as matching a job to the right tool. Just like you wouldn't use a sledgehammer to hang a picture frame, you wouldn't use a metre ruler to measure the diameter of a wire (0.2 mm — you'd barely see it against the ruler's 1 mm markings, let alone read it accurately).
Apparatus falls into two jobs: what you're measuring (the thing being investigated — e.g. an aluminium block) and how you're measuring it (the instruments — thermometer, ammeter, voltmeter, etc).
| Quantity | Apparatus |
|---|---|
| Length | Metre ruler, Vernier calipers, Micrometer screw gauge |
| Mass | Top-pan balance |
| Angle | Protractor |
| Time | Stopwatch |
| Temperature | Thermometer |
| Potential difference | Voltmeter |
| Current | Ammeter |
| Frequency | Oscilloscope (CRO) |
To find Young modulus, you need: diameter of the wire (micrometer — highest resolution for tiny widths), original length (metre ruler), extension (a travelling microscope — designed for tiny length changes), and mass/weight applied (top-pan balance, or a newton-meter to check the masses directly). Notice the pattern: for every measurement, you pick the instrument with the resolution that actually matches the size of the thing you're measuring.
📏 2. Range & Resolution of Instruments
These two words get mixed up constantly, so lock in the difference now:
- Range — the highest and lowest value the instrument measure. Think "how far it stretches."
- Resolution — the smallest change the instrument can detect. Think "how fine its teeth are."
A bathroom scale has a huge range (0–150 kg) but poor resolution (nearest 0.5 kg) — great for weighing yourself, useless for weighing a letter for postage.
| Instrument | Typical Resolution | Typical Range |
|---|---|---|
| Metre ruler | 1 mm | 0 – 1 m |
| Vernier calipers | 0.1 mm | 0 – 300 mm |
| Micrometer screw gauge | 0.01 mm | 0 – 25 mm |
| Top-pan balance | 0.01 g | 0 – 1 kg |
| Protractor | 1° | 0 – 180° |
| Stopwatch | 0.01 s | up to ~10 hrs |
| Thermometer | 1 °C | −10 °C – 110 °C |
| Voltmeter | 1 mV – 0.1 V | 0 – 1000 V |
| Ammeter | 1 mA – 0.1 A | 0 – 10 A |
🎯 3. Calibrating Instruments
Calibration means comparing your instrument's reading against a known, trusted value. If a thermometer says a boiling kettle is at 94°C, but you know water boils at 100°C (at standard pressure), the thermometer is wrong by a consistent 6°C — and calibration is how you'd catch and correct that.
The simplest form of calibration is a zero check: before taking readings, confirm a meter reads exactly zero with no input. If it doesn't, you have a "zero error," which is a type of systematic error.
To calibrate a thermometer properly, you mark 0°C at the freezing point of pure water (melting ice) and 100°C at the boiling point of water, then divide the space between into equal degree markings.
iCalibration Curves
Some sensors (like thermistors or thermocouples) don't give a reading directly in the unit you want — a thermocouple outputs a voltage (e.m.f.), not a temperature. A calibration curve is a graph that lets you convert the sensor's raw output into the real physical quantity, by plotting the sensor's output against a known reference.
Take your measured reading (say, a voltage from a thermocouple) on the y-axis, trace a horizontal line to the curve, then drop straight down to read off the corresponding temperature on the x-axis. This is exactly how the "unknown temperature for a particular p.d." example in the chapter works.
📐 4. Measuring Variables
This topic is really an extension of Topic 1 and 2 combined into a decision-making skill: given a specific measurement task, pick the instrument whose resolution is appropriate for the size of the thing you're measuring.
⚖️ 5. Control Variables & Fair Tests
Every experiment has three types of variable, and mixing them up is one of the most common ways to lose marks:
- Independent variable — the ONE thing you deliberately change.
- Dependent variable — the thing you measure as a result (the outcome).
- Control variables — everything else that could affect the result, which you must keep constant.
A fair test is one where only the independent variable is allowed to influence the dependent variable. If you don't control the other variables, you can't be sure it was your independent variable causing the change you saw — the result becomes unreliable.
In circuits, resistance of a component changes with temperature. Current flowing through a wire heats it up over time (think of your laptop charger getting warm). So unless you're specifically investigating resistance vs. temperature, temperature must be controlled — usually by disconnecting the power supply between readings to let the component cool back down.
iWorked Example: Charles' Law vs Boyle's Law
| Law | Independent | Dependent | Control |
|---|---|---|---|
| Charles' Law | Temperature | Volume | Pressure, number of moles |
| Boyle's Law | Pressure | Volume | Temperature, number of moles |
Notice: in an ideal gas investigation there are four possible factors (temperature, pressure, volume, moles), but only one is ever changed deliberately at a time — everything else must be locked down.
🔁 6. Repeat Readings
Taking repeat readings and averaging them reduces the effect of random error, making your data more precise (small spread) and more reliable (trustworthy, not a fluke). Repeats also let you spot an anomaly — a result that clearly doesn't fit the pattern of the others, which you'd typically exclude before averaging.
But repeats aren't automatically the right call for every experiment. Ask:
Electrical circuits: components heat up with use, which changes resistance and affects results. To repeat fairly, you'd need to disconnect the power, let it cool, then redo the entire experiment — which can take a very long time across a wide range of readings.
Time-dependent variables: if you're measuring something tied to a specific time of day (e.g. radiation levels at 6–7am), you can't just repeat it minutes later — you'd have to wait until the next day, which may not fit your time budget.
🦺 7. Health & Safety
This is the easiest topic to lose marks on despite being the "simplest" — because examiners want a hazard + a specific fix, not just "be careful."
Edexcel IAL exams often ask "comment on safety" for just 1 mark. Don't just say "wires can become too hot" — that alone doesn't score. Say you'd deal with it: "turn off the power supply between readings to let wires cool down." Hazard + fix = the mark.
📊 8. Data Collection
Once you've collected raw readings, you often need to process them before they're useful — usually by getting your data into the form of a straight line, because straight-line graphs are the easiest way to test a relationship and extract meaningful constants.
iStandard Form & Prefixes
Standard form avoids writing out long strings of zeros — e.g. the speed of light is 3.00 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹ rather than 300,000,000 m s⁻¹.
| Prefix | Symbol | Power of ten |
|---|---|---|
| Giga | G | 10⁹ |
| Mega | M | 10⁶ |
| Kilo | k | 10³ |
| Centi | c | 10⁻² |
| Milli | m | 10⁻³ |
| Micro | μ | 10⁻⁶ |
| Nano | n | 10⁻⁹ |
iiSignificant Figures & Means
Every value in a single data column should be quoted to the same number of significant figures — mixing 22.0, 39.5, 60, 81.44, 100 in one column (as in the chapter's example) looks sloppy and inconsistent. Round them all to match, e.g. 20.0, 40.0, 60.0, 80.0, 100.0.
When you calculate a mean from repeat readings, you're allowed to quote it to one extra significant figure beyond your raw data — because averaging genuinely does improve your precision slightly.
iiiGraph Skills
- Recognising when a relationship fits
y = mx + cso gradient/intercept can be analysed - Finding the area under a graph (including non-linear curves, by estimation)
- Using and interpreting logarithmic plots
- Drawing tangents to curves and calculating their gradient
- Understanding when asymptotes are needed
🎯 9. Uncertainty & Systematic Errors
This is probably the most conceptually important — and most confused — topic in the chapter. Let's build it up carefully.
Uncertainty is a around your measurement within which the true value is expected to lie — it's an honest admission that you can't be 100% precise. Example: "mass = 952 ± 2 g" means the true value is thought to lie somewhere between 950 g and 954 g.
An error is the actual gap between your measured result and the true value (if a true value exists) — it's not a mistake, it's the real discrepancy caused by imperfect equipment or method. If the true mass is 950 g but your balance reads 952 g, the is +2 g, and the you'd quote (before knowing the true value) might also be ±2 g, since it's an estimate of how big that error could plausibly be.
Reducing uncertainty — three practical strategies:
- Take repeat readings (3–5) and calculate the mean
- For non-uniform objects (like a wire), measure at multiple points to check uniformity
- Use the instrument with the appropriate resolution for the size of the quantity (don't use a ruler for millimetre-scale gaps)
iSystematic Errors
A systematic error comes from a faulty instrument or a flawed method, and — crucially — it's : it shifts every single reading by roughly the same amount, in the same direction. This consistency is exactly why it shows up so clearly on a graph.
Reducing systematic errors: recalibrate the instrument (or swap it for a different one), or adjust/correct the technique being used.
Fringe spacing in an interference pattern is tiny and hard to pinpoint precisely (the bright fringes can look "smeared out"). Instead of measuring one fringe spacing, measure across fringes (a much bigger, easier-to-read distance) and divide by the number of spacings. The exact same trick works for timing oscillations: time 10 oscillations and divide by 10, rather than timing just 1 — this shrinks the relative impact of your reaction-time error.
🌍 10. Wider Implications
Physics doesn't happen in a vacuum (pun intended) — every experiment or new technology has knock-on consequences beyond the lab. Examiners expect you to recognise four core categories, often abbreviated C.L.E.S.:
Beyond these four, also consider economic factors (is the research worth the cost vs. other priorities like schools/healthcare — but weighed against long-term benefits like climate mitigation) and environmental factors (impact on wildlife/geography — e.g. wind turbines are clean energy but can harm birds and bats).
🧠 What to Memorise
✅ Concepts Checklist
🎓 Exam Tips & Common Traps
Don't confuse resolution with range
"This instrument can't measure that" is a range problem. "This instrument can't measure that precisely" is a resolution problem. Examiners test both separately — read the question carefully to see which is actually being asked.
Safety answers need a fix, not just a hazard
"Wires might get hot" alone rarely scores. Always pair the hazard with the specific action taken to prevent it, e.g. "...so disconnect the power supply between readings."
Uncertainty and error are NOT interchangeable terms
Using them as synonyms in an exam answer can lose marks. Uncertainty = an estimated range; error = the actual (often unknown) discrepancy from the true value.
Always justify apparatus choices with resolution
Don't just say "use a micrometer" — say "use a micrometer because it has the highest resolution for measuring very small lengths accurately." The justification is usually where the mark actually sits.
Systematic errors show up as an offset, not a random scatter
If asked to identify a systematic error from a graph, look for a line that's shifted (parallel but not through the expected origin) — not a wide scatter of points, which instead suggests random error.
Repeats aren't automatically "the answer"
If asked to evaluate a method, don't default to "just do more repeats." Consider whether repeats are actually practical given time constraints, heating effects, or time-of-day dependence — and explain your reasoning either way.
- 📏 2. Range & Resolution of Instruments
- ⚖️ 5. Control Variables & Fair Tests
- 🦺 7. Health & Safety
- 🎯 9. Uncertainty & Systematic Errors
- 🎓 Exam Tips & Common Traps
- iStandard Form & Prefixes
- iiSignificant Figures & Means
Read the full Practical Skills I: Planning notes free
That's the preview — create a free account to read the rest, plus flashcards and practice questions with instant AI marking. No credit card.
Unlock the full notes free →