Library Geometric & Negative Binomial Distributions
Further Mathematics

Geometric & Negative Binomial Distributions

Revise Geometric & Negative Binomial Distributions for Further Mathematics — revision notes and instant AI marking. Free to start.

📖 Revision notes · preview
Edexcel A Level Further Maths · Further Statistics 1

Geometric & Negative Binomial Distributions

The big idea: both distributions answer the same kind of question — "how many tries will it take?" — the Geometric distribution counts trials until the first success, and the Negative Binomial counts trials until the r-th success. In fact, Geometric is just Negative Binomial with r = 1.

Summary — Everything In This Chapter

  • Geometric distribution X ~ Geo(p): models the number of trials needed to get the first success.
  • Four conditions must hold: indefinite trials, independence, two outcomes per trial, constant probability of success.
  • PMF: P(X = x) = p(1−p)x−1, for x = 1, 2, 3, …
  • CDF: P(X ≤ x) = 1 − (1−p)x, and P(X > x) = (1−p)x
  • Mean E(X) = 1/p, Variance Var(X) = (1−p)/p²
  • The Geometric distribution has no memory — past failures don't affect future probabilities.
  • The mode is always X = 1 (probabilities strictly decrease from the first trial onward).
  • Negative Binomial X ~ Negative B(r, p): models the number of trials needed to get a fixed number, r, of successes.
  • Same four conditions as Geometric, but now r successes are required instead of just 1.
  • PMF: P(X = x) = x−1Cr−1 · pr(1−p)x−r, for x = r, r+1, r+2, …
  • Mean E(X) = r/p, Variance Var(X) = r(1−p)/p²
  • When r = 1, the Negative Binomial formula collapses exactly into the Geometric formula.

Topic 1 — The Geometric Distribution

1.1 What is it actually modelling?

Picture rolling a die and waiting for your first six. You don't know if it'll take 1 roll, 5 rolls, or 50 rolls — but eventually (with probability 1) it will happen. The Geometric distribution is the tool for exactly this situation: counting trials until the very first success happens.

We write X ~ Geo(p), where:

  • X = the number of trials it takes to get the first success (so X = 8 means the first success happened on the 8th go, meaning the first 7 were failures)
  • p = the fixed probability of success on any single trial
Think of it like this
A Binomial distribution fixes the number of trials (n) and asks "how many successes?". A Geometric distribution flips that around — it fixes the number of successes (just 1) and asks "how many trials did it take?". Same underlying coin-flipping/dice-rolling world, different question.

1.2 The four conditions (and when they break)

A Geometric model is only valid if all four of these hold:

  1. The experiment consists of an indefinite number of successive trials
  2. The outcome of each trial is independent of all the others
  3. Each trial has exactly two possible outcomes (success / failure)
  4. The probability of success is constant, p, on every trial
Where models break down
Examiners love asking you to criticise a Geometric model. The classic answer: "if the person is repeating an activity, they might get better with practice, so trials aren't really independent and p isn't really constant." Always swap the word "trials" for the actual context (e.g. "rolls of the dice", "phone calls made") when you write this out — generic answers lose marks.

1.3 The probability formula

Probability Mass Function
P(X = x) = p(1 − p)x − 1,   x = 1, 2, 3, …
In plain words: to succeed for the first time exactly on trial x, you must first fail (x − 1) times in a row — probability (1−p)x−1 — and then succeed on that final trial — probability p. Multiply those together (independence!) and that's your formula.

A neat pattern worth noticing: the sequence of probabilities P(X=1), P(X=2), P(X=3), … is p, p(1−p), p(1−p)², … — a geometric sequence with first term p and common ratio (1−p). That's literally where the distribution gets its name. Since 0 < (1−p) < 1, this sequence is always decreasing, which means P(X=1) is always the biggest probability — so the mode of a Geometric distribution is always X = 1, no matter what p is.

1.4 The "no memory" property

This is the single most elegant idea in the whole chapter, so let's really unpack it. Suppose you've already failed 5 times in a row. What's the probability the first success happens on trial 7 (i.e. 2 more trials from now)?

Your gut might say "well, it's been failing a lot, so a success is 'due' soon" — but that's wrong, and it's a famous fallacy (the gambler's fallacy). Because each trial is independent, the die/coin has no memory of what happened before. The probability of succeeding exactly 2 trials from now is simply p(1−p) — identical to the probability of succeeding on trial 2 if you were starting completely fresh.

Memoryless, formally
P(X = n + k | X > n) = P(X = k). Given that the first n trials were all failures, the probability that it takes k more trials to succeed is exactly the same as if you'd never started — the process "resets" after every failure.

1.5 The cumulative distribution

Cumulative Geometric Distribution
P(X ≤ x) = 1 − (1 − p)x,   x = 1, 2, 3, …
P(X ≤ x) is the probability the first success happens on or before trial x. It's easiest to prove by thinking about the complement: "NOT succeeding by trial x" means failing all x times in a row, which has probability (1−p)x. Subtract that from 1 and you're done.

From this you instantly get P(X > x) = (1 − p)x — the probability you need more than x trials, which is just "fail x times in a row." This little formula shows up constantly in exam questions, so it's worth knowing without deriving it every time.

1.6 Mean and variance

Geometric Mean & Variance
E(X) = 1/p
Var(X) = (1 − p)/p²
Makes intuitive sense: if success is rare (small p), you expect to wait a long time (large 1/p) — e.g. if p = 0.1, you expect it to take 10 trials on average.
Exam tip
If a question gives you the mean or standard deviation and asks you to find p, just plug the given value into E(X) = 1/p or Var(X) = (1−p)/p² and solve the resulting equation. Watch out for quadratics with two solutions — reject any negative p, since probabilities can never be negative!

1.7 Worked example — walking through it properly

Joshua inspects widgets from a machine until he finds a defective one. The probability any widget is defective is 0.002. Let X = number of widgets inspected until the first defective one, so X ~ Geo(0.002).

a) Find P(the 10th widget is the first defective one), i.e. P(X = 10).

Using P(X = x) = p(1−p)x−1:

P(X = 10) = 0.002 × (0.998)9 = 0.00196428… ≈ 0.00196

b) Find P(X = 250):

P(X = 250) = 0.002 × (0.998)2490.00121

c) Find P(X = 250 | X > 240) — given the first 240 widgets were fine, find P the 250th is the first defective one.

This is exactly where the memoryless property saves you time. Since the process resets after every "failure" (non-defective widget), this conditional probability is the same as asking for the probability of the first defective occurring on the 10th widget starting fresh:

P(X = 250 | X > 240) = P(X = 10) ≈ 0.00196 — identical to part (a)!

d) Find P(X ≤ 250) — Joshua inspects 250 or fewer before finding a defective one.

P(X ≤ 250) = 1 − (0.998)250 = 0.393772… ≈ 0.394

e) Find P(X > 250) — he needs more than 250 inspections.

P(X > 250) = (0.998)250 = 0.606227… ≈ 0.606

Practice Question 1

A biased dice has P(landing on a 6) = p. The random variable X is the number of rolls needed to get the first six. Given that the standard deviation of X is 2√3, find (a) the value of p, (b) E(X), (c) P(X ≤ 3).

Practice Question 2

A machine produces faulty components with fixed probability p per component, independently. Explain, in the context of this question, why the Geometric distribution might not be an appropriate model, and state what assumption you'd need to make to proceed anyway.


Topic 2 — The Negative Binomial Distribution

2.1 What is it actually modelling?

Now imagine you're not stopping at the first six — you're rolling until you get your third six. That's the Negative Binomial distribution: it counts the number of trials needed to reach a fixed number of successes, r.

We write X ~ Negative B(r, p) (also sometimes written NB(r, p)), where:

  • X = number of trials needed to reach a total of r successes
  • r = the fixed target number of successes
  • p = the fixed probability of success on any one trial
The three-way comparison
Binomial B(n, p): n is fixed, you count successes.
Geometric Geo(p): you stop at 1 success, you count trials.
Negative Binomial NB(r, p): r successes fixed, you count trials.

2.2 Conditions — identical logic to Geometric

Same four conditions apply, just with "r successes" instead of "1 success":

  1. Indefinite number of successive trials
  2. Independent trials
  3. Two outcomes per trial (success/failure)
  4. Constant probability of success, p

The same criticism applies too: if someone improves with practice while chasing their r-th success, independence and constant p both come into question.

2.3 Where the formula comes from

This is worth really understanding rather than memorising blind, because it shows up in the reasoning of harder exam questions. Say you want the 3rd six to land exactly on the 12th roll of a fair die. Two things must both happen:

  1. Exactly 2 sixes occur somewhere in the first 11 rolls (it doesn't matter which 2 of the 11) — this is a plain Binomial probability, P(Y = 2) for Y ~ B(11, 1/6)
  2. AND a six occurs on the 12th roll itself — probability p

Multiply these together (independence again) and you get the general Negative Binomial formula. This is exactly why the formula contains a binomial coefficient — you're really doing a Binomial calculation for the first (x−1) trials, then bolting on one guaranteed success at the very end.

Probability Mass Function
P(X = x) = x−1Cr−1 · pr(1−p)x−r,   x = r, r+1, r+2, …
In plain words: choose which (r−1) of the first (x−1) trials were successes — x−1Cr−1 ways — multiply by the probability of getting exactly that many successes and failures in those trials, then multiply by p for the guaranteed success on the final, x-th trial.

2.4 The connection back to Geometric

Set r = 1 in the Negative Binomial formula and watch what happens:

P(X = x) = x−1C0 · p1(1−p)x−1 = p(1−p)x−1
…which is exactly the Geometric PMF. So Geometric isn't a separate idea — it's simply the r = 1 special case of Negative Binomial.
Exam tip
If a question describes "first success" language, you can use either Geo(p) or NB(1, p) — they give identical answers. Using Geo(p) is usually faster to write out.

2.5 Mean and variance

Negative Binomial Mean & Variance
E(X) = r/p
Var(X) = r(1−p)/p²
Notice these are exactly r times the Geometric formulas. That makes sense — reaching r successes takes roughly r times as long as reaching just 1, on average.

2.6 Worked example — one scenario, five different question types

Emanuel plays chess in a tournament where his probability of winning any one game is 0.55. This single set-up is a great illustration of how Binomial, Geometric, and Negative Binomial can all appear in the same question depending on exactly what's being asked.

a) His first win is in the third game he plays.

This is asking for the first success on trial 3 — use X ~ Geo(0.55), or equivalently NB(1, 0.55):

P(X = 3) = (0.55)(0.45)² = 0.111375 ≈ 0.111

b) He wins exactly 4 of his first 7 games.

Careful — this is not a "trials until success" question at all. The number of games (7) is fixed and we're counting wins, so this is a regular Binomial: X ~ B(7, 0.55).

P(X = 4) = 7C4(0.55)⁴(0.45)³ = 0.291847… ≈ 0.292

c) He wins for the fourth time in his seventh game.

Now we're fixing the number of successes (4) and asking about the trial count — Negative Binomial. X ~ Negative B(4, 0.55):

P(X = 7) = 6C3(0.55)⁴(0.45)³ = 0.166770… ≈ 0.167

d) He wins for the fourth time in his seventh game, given that he won his first game.

If game 1 was already a win, he now needs 3 more wins within the remaining 6 games, with the 4th win landing exactly on game 6 of those remaining games. So use X ~ Negative B(3, 0.55):

P(X = 6) = 5C2(0.55)³(0.45)³ = 0.151609… ≈ 0.152

e) His fourth win occurs in or before his seventh game.

This is subtly different again — "in or before game 7" means at least 4 wins within a fixed 7 games, which flips it back into a Binomial cumulative question: X ~ B(7, 0.55), find P(X ≥ 4).

P(X ≥ 4) = 1 − P(X ≤ 3) = 0.608287… ≈ 0.608

The trap students fall into
Parts (c) and (e) look almost identical on a first read but need completely different distributions. The keyword to hunt for is whether the number of trials is fixed ("in his first 7 games" → Binomial) or the number of successes is fixed and you're finding the trial it lands on ("wins for the fourth time in his seventh game" → Negative Binomial). Always ask: is the fixed number here a trial-count or a success-count?
Practice Question 3

Croesus tosses a biased coin with P(heads) = p repeatedly. Let X = number of tosses needed to get the fourth head. Given E(X) = 10, find (a) p, (b) the standard deviation of X, (c) the probability the fourth head occurs on exactly the seventh toss.

Practice Question 4

Explain briefly why P(X = x) for the Negative Binomial distribution, with r = 1, reduces exactly to the Geometric distribution formula. What does this tell you about the relationship between the two distributions?


What to Memorise

Concept Geometric — X ~ Geo(p) Negative Binomial — X ~ Negative B(r, p)
Models Trials until the 1st success Trials until the r-th success
Range of X x = 1, 2, 3, … x = r, r+1, r+2, …
PMF P(X=x) = p(1−p)x−1 P(X=x) = x−1Cr−1pr(1−p)x−r
CDF P(X≤x) = 1 − (1−p)x No simple closed form — sum PMF terms or use calculator
Mean E(X) = 1/p E(X) = r/p
Variance Var(X) = (1−p)/p² Var(X) = r(1−p)/p²
Special properties Memoryless; mode always = 1 Reduces to Geometric when r = 1
The four shared conditions (memorise word for word)
1. Indefinite number of successive trials  ·  2. Independent outcomes  ·  3. Exactly two outcomes per trial  ·  4. Constant probability of success, p.

Concepts Checklist

Exam Tips & Common Mistakes

Mixing up which distribution to use

The single biggest source of lost marks. Ask yourself: is the number of trials fixed (→ Binomial, counting successes) or is the number of successes fixed (→ Geometric if it's 1, Negative Binomial if it's r, counting trials)?

Off-by-one errors in the exponent

Remember it's (1−p)x−1 in the Geometric PMF, not (1−p)x. You need x−1 failures before the single success on trial x — count carefully.

Forgetting the memoryless shortcut

Conditional questions like "given the first n trials failed, find P(success happens k more trials later)" collapse instantly to P(X=k) — you don't need to build a fraction with conditional probability from scratch.

Generic "not independent" answers

When asked to criticise a model, always tie your answer to the specific context given (e.g. "the dice may become worn" or "the player may improve with practice") — vague textbook phrasing without context loses marks.

Rejecting negative probabilities

When you solve a quadratic for p (from a mean/variance equation), always check both roots and explicitly state you're rejecting the negative one because "p is a probability, so 0 < p < 1."

Use your calculator's built-in functions

Most exam calculators have Geometric and Cumulative Geometric probability functions built in. Learn where they are — it saves time and reduces arithmetic slips, especially with large exponents like (0.998)249.

Also in the full note
  • Exam Tips & Common Mistakes
What's inside
📖 Revision notes ✦ AI flashcards ✓ Instant AI marking

Read the full Geometric & Negative Binomial Distributions notes free

That's the preview — create a free account to read the rest, plus flashcards and practice questions with instant AI marking. No credit card.

Unlock the full notes free →